Assistant

evaluation-report.pdfPDF · 2.4 MB · 18 pagesresults-chart.pngImage · 1600 × 900
Summarise the attached evaluation report and compare the three approaches it describes. A table would help.
Assistant· Apex Standard

I’ve read the report and the chart. Here is a short summary, then a side-by-side comparison of the three approaches.

Summary

  • All three approaches improve on the baseline; the gap between them is small on simple tasks and wider on multi-step tasks.
  • Approach B is the most accurate but the slowest by a clear margin.
  • Approach C gives most of the benefit at a fraction of the cost, with weaker results on long inputs.

Comparison

ApproachStrengthTrade-offBest for
A — Baseline plus retrievalSimple to operateLimited on multi-step tasksLookup and Q&A
B — Staged reasoningHighest accuracySlowest, most computeComplex analysis
C — RoutedLow cost per taskWeaker on long inputsHigh-volume work

If you want to reproduce the comparison from the raw results, this loads the file and groups by approach:

python
import pandas as pd

results = pd.read_csv("results.csv")
summary = (results.groupby("approach")
           .agg(accuracy=("correct", "mean"), latency=("seconds", "median")))
print(summary.round(3))
Sourcesevaluation-report.pdf · p. 4evaluation-report.pdf · p. 11results-chart.png

The assistant can make mistakes. Check important information.